A recent decision by a northern school might make some kids rethink their Christmas lists, in case they get accused of showing off!
In the new year Woodchurch High School in Birkenhead near Liverpool will ban their pupils from wearing expensive coats, in an attempt to stop bullying linked to “poverty shaming”. Brands that face the ban include Moncler coats that cost from £650 to £9,175.
The decision has sparked heavy debate online. For example Michigan priest Joseph Krupp saw the ban as part of an effort to “…alleviate all suffering…” which would only succeed in “lowering the bar of what constitutes suffering.”
At some point, we have to realize that we are made to suffer.
Until then, our efforts to alleviate all suffering is only succeeding in lowering the bar of what constitutes suffering.High school bans luxury coats to prevent ‘poverty shaming’ https://t.co/Mfbq9r4wQA
— Fr. Joseph Krupp (@Joeinblack) November 17, 2018
But other people welcomed the ban. One parent tweeted saying: ‘@RadioCityTalk Mick my son goes too Woodchurch High. He has been asking for one of these coats for Xmas…Since the school announced this he has told us not too bother as he can’t wear it for school.. Result for me’.
I spoke with a schoolteacher in East London, who agreed with the Reverend Krupp. “There shouldn’t be a problem with students coming into school with their expensive designer coat. If they have wealthy parents that can provide luxury items for them then why not? I think it’s unfair that certain students must hide or even change their preferences due to other students.” But teachers up in Birkenhead claimed their approach was popular with parents. “Support from parents/carers has been overwhelmingly positive,” read a letter to parents, “and we are very thankful for this.”
The letter went on to say that, “Some have also asked whether Pyrenex coats, which are also in a similar price range (with some also having real fur) will also be prohibited. I am writing to confirm that these brands will also be prohibited after Christmas. Thank you for your ongoing support.” So while down here protesters can often be spotted in London protesting against the use of real fur, in the Wirral it’s the cost, not the animals, that is upsetting parents and teachers.
Personally I agree with the reverend. By shielding kids from what they will be exposed to in the future, they might end up with an unrealistic view of life. People compare everything – from shoes to cars. But they are only sometimes stupid enough to judge people because of their possessions as well.
